Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Key West, FL

Real data · NAIC State Based Systems

184 verified agents. Average 8.9 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.

Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 3 ZIPs.

Key West at a glance

Active licenses

100%

184 of 184

License lines

5

distinct authorities

Multi-state

2

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

5 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs44%(74)5-10 yrs25%(43)10-20 yrs14%(23)20+ yrs17%(29)

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance99Life Insurance51Property Insurance24Health Insurance6Title Insurance4

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–30 of 100

David Freeman

Property Insurance+Casualty

PORTER-ALLEN COMPANY INC

Key West, FL · 3304068 yrs licensedNPN 473387Lic #A089729
active

A Lujan

Property Insurance+Casualty

SOUTHERNMOST INSURANCE AGENCY

Key West, FL · 3304049 yrs licensedNPN 487593Lic #A160070
active

Dean Wahlstrom

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property

201 FRONT STREET

Key West, FL · 3304047 yrs licensedNPN 23637Lic #A275447
active

Tim Tomita

Property Insurance+Casualty

ISLAND INSURANCE AGENCY INC

Key West, FL · 3304040 yrs licensedNPN 620215Lic #A266382
active

David Kincaid

Property Insurance+Casualty

422 FLEMING ST STE 7

Key West, FL · 3304037 yrs licensedNPN 402962Lic #A141114
active

Norman Fuller

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more

THE FULLERS INC

Key West, FL · 3304037 yrs licensedNPN 444125Lic #A091203
active

Ayden Phillips

Property Insurance+Casualty

ISLAND INSURANCE AGENCY INC

Key West, FL · 3304036 yrs licensedNPN 585232Lic #A206346
active

Christine Hernandez

Property Insurance+Casualty

FOUNDATION RISK PARTNERS DBA KEY WEST INSURANCE

Key West, FL · 3304035 yrs licensedNPN 489683Lic #A117278
active

Michael Ryan

Casualty Insurance

BILL RYAN BAIL BOND SERVICE

Key West, FL · 3304035 yrs licensedNPN 3601275Lic #A229212
active

Phillip Miani

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

302 SOUTHARD STREET

Key West, FL · 3304035 yrs licensedNPN 382004Lic #A177877
active

Lisa Blanco-Vigil

Casualty Insurance

MONROE COUNTY BAIL BONDS

Key West, FL · 3304033 yrs licensedNPN 3595216Lic #A023335
active

Elizabeth Freeman

Property Insurance+Casualty

THE PORTER ALLEN COMPANY INC

Key West, FL · 3304032 yrs licensedNPN 489692Lic #A089742
active

John Parks

Casualty Insurance

BANK OF AMERICA/MERRILL LYNCH

Key West, FL · 3304030 yrs licensedNPN 596644Lic #A200694
active

Christina Ryan

Casualty Insurance

BILL RYAN BAIL BONDS

Key West, FL · 3304029 yrs licensedNPN 3576322Lic #A097412
active

Deborah Condella

Title Insurance

3432 DUCK AVENUE

Key West, FL · 3304027 yrs licensedNPN 2084731Lic #A311803
active

Thomas Nitti

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

RAYMOND JAMES & ASSOCIATES

Key West, FL · 3304026 yrs licensedNPN 3182078Lic #D023202
active

Merton Cawood

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

320 PEACON LANE

Key West, FL · 3304025 yrs licensed2 statesNPN 636050Lic #A043927
active

Manuel Ortega

Casualty Insurance

M & E BONDING AGENCY

Key West, FL · 3304024 yrs licensedNPN 4010058Lic #D068559
active

Charles Gonzalez

Casualty Insurance

900 18TH TERRACE

Key West, FL · 3304024 yrs licensedNPN 3743607Lic #D059998
active

Joelle Fuller

Property Insurance+Casualty

FULLERS INC

Key West, FL · 3304024 yrs licensedNPN 444126Lic #A091179
active

Michael Deroche

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

BANK OF AMERICA/MERRILL LYNCH

Key West, FL · 3304023 yrs licensedNPN 2650194Lic #D057284
active

Cindy Rhoades

Casualty Insurance

MOLLY PARKER, INC.

Key West, FL · 3304022 yrs licensedNPN 7940016Lic #E097006
active

Sandra Lee

Property Insurance+Casualty

KEY WEST INSURANCE

Key West, FL · 3304022 yrs licensedNPN 3540088Lic #D046751
active

Phillip Condella

Title Insurance

3432 DUCK AVENUE

Key West, FL · 3304021 yrs licensedNPN 8196920Lic #E124977
active

James Gibson

Property Insurance+Casualty+Surplus

SOUTHERNMOST INSURANCE AGENCY

Key West, FL · 3304021 yrs licensedNPN 8194383Lic #E138177
active

Philip Sheldon

Casualty Insurance

% MELFABCO

Key West, FL · 3304021 yrs licensedNPN 8335237Lic #E158373
active

Jack Niles

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

NW&M FINANCIAL CONSULTING INC

Key West, FL · 3304021 yrs licensedNPN 8270237Lic #E148808
active

Paul Hayes

Casualty Insurance

RENT KEY WEST VACATIONS

Key West, FL · 3304020 yrs licensedNPN 8556068Lic #P040200
active

Emily Brouilette

Life Insurance+Health+Variable

AMERIPRISE FINANCIAL

Key West, FL · 3304020 yrs licensedNPN 7362226Lic #E126846
active

Laura Mcchesney

Casualty Insurance

520 SOUTHARD STREET

Key West, FL · 3304019 yrs licensedNPN 8843972Lic #P069714
active