Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
Home Florida Sanibel Insurance Agents in Sanibel, FL Real data · NAIC State Based Systems45 verified agents. Average 9.9 years licensed.
Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 2 ZIPs.
Sanibel at a glance Tenure distribution
0-5 yrs 48% (20) 5-10 yrs 12% (5) 10-20 yrs 19% (8) 20+ yrs 21% (9)
Browse by ZIP
All ZIPs 33957 44 33919 1
All lines Casualty Insurance (15) Life Insurance (15) Property Insurance (10) Title Insurance (5) Showing 1–30 of 45
Frances Peters Casualty Insurance
1101 PERIWINKLE WAY #108
Sanibel, FL · 33957 32 yrs licensed NPN 481065 Lic #A205225 active
Merrell Rushworth Property Insurance +Casualty
HEIDRICK & CO
Sanibel, FL · 33919 29 yrs licensed NPN 502595 Lic #A228525 active
Angela Roehl Life Insurance +Casualty +Health +Property
1200 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 29 yrs licensed NPN 593485 Lic #A150040 active
Sharon Michie Casualty Insurance
COTTAGES TO CASTLES OF SANIBEL
Sanibel, FL · 33957 28 yrs licensed NPN 1640200 Lic #A178096 active
Richard Rodriguez Life Insurance +Health
1572 SERENITY LANE
Sanibel, FL · 33957 27 yrs licensed NPN 507713 Lic #D001887 active
Thomas Intogna Casualty Insurance
PARADISE DESTINATIONS INC
Sanibel, FL · 33957 27 yrs licensed NPN 2225655 Lic #A307988 active
Michelle Landl Title Insurance
1456 PERIWINKLE WAY, SUITE C
Sanibel, FL · 33957 23 yrs licensed NPN 7464205 Lic #E049133 active
Richard Zurbriggen Life Insurance +Health +Variable
695 TARPON BAY ROAD
Sanibel, FL · 33957 21 yrs licensed NPN 2162434 Lic #E041702 active
Mark Hembling Life Insurance +Health +Variable
1349 EAGLE RUN DR
Sanibel, FL · 33957 20 yrs licensed NPN 8669732 Lic #P026343 active
J Boyle Casualty Insurance
2230 CAMINO DEL MAR
Sanibel, FL · 33957 19 yrs licensed NPN 9400768 Lic #P114803 active
Rebecca Cosentino Casualty Insurance
SANIBEL HOLIDAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 19 yrs licensed NPN 8329735 Lic #P074401 active
Amanda Curran Title Insurance
1101 PERIWINKLE WAY SUITE 102
Sanibel, FL · 33957 16 yrs licensed NPN 15764081 Lic #P235232 active
Joel Kronfeld Casualty Insurance
3951 WEST GULF DRIVE
Sanibel, FL · 33957 14 yrs licensed NPN 16481742 Lic #W075716 active
Jeremy Jackson Casualty Insurance
1200 PERIWINKLE WAY SUITE 2
Sanibel, FL · 33957 12 yrs licensed NPN 17187297 Lic #W178281 active
Diane Wight Life Insurance +Health +Variable
1119 PERIWINKLE WAY #351
Sanibel, FL · 33957 11 yrs licensed NPN 8147408 Lic #W071736 active
Holli Martin Property Insurance +Casualty
1648 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 11 yrs licensed NPN 2155428 Lic #W211930 active
Chassiddy Brown Property Insurance +Casualty
1649 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 10 yrs licensed NPN 8775297 Lic #P064569 active
Tamara Treuheit Property Insurance +Casualty
1648 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 8 yrs licensed NPN 18215617 Lic #W372096 active
Riley Nowell Life Insurance +Health +Variable
1141 PAPER FIG COURT
Sanibel, FL · 33957 8 yrs licensed NPN 18816312 Lic #W491782 active
Ronald Congdon Casualty Insurance
605 DONAX STREET
Sanibel, FL · 33957 8 yrs licensed NPN 18684421 Lic #W465195 active
Paul Gulbrandsen Property Insurance +Casualty
828 RABBIT RD
Sanibel, FL · 33957 6 yrs licensed NPN 18887714 Lic #W507519 active
Eric Siefert Casualty Insurance
2441 PALM RIDGE ROAD
Sanibel, FL · 33957 6 yrs licensed NPN 18912239 Lic #W621272 active
Steven Ranke Property Insurance +Casualty
1648 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 472302 Lic #A215072 active
Daniel Fase Life Insurance +Health +Variable
1250 TENNISPLACE CT #A36
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 8196502 Lic #E122503 active
Jessica Hadu Casualty Insurance
1648 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 11127136 Lic #P165144 active
Joseph Connelly Life Insurance +Health +Variable
3355 BARRA CIRCLE
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 2065993 Lic #W584663 active
Emily Mcgahey Property Insurance +Casualty
1648 PERIWINKLE WAY, STE A
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 19833624 Lic #W726996 active
Ronald Philleo Life Insurance +Casualty +Health +Property +1 more
1225 SEAGRAPE LANE
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 6501581 Lic #W725302 active
Melissa Byrne Casualty Insurance
1200 PERIWINKLE WAY
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 20160337 Lic #W808004 active
Rebekah Cain Property Insurance +Casualty
1648 PERWINKLE WAY SUITE A
Sanibel, FL · 33957 4 yrs licensed NPN 20079286 Lic #W784129 active Prev1 2 Next