Insurance Agents in Columbus, IN
Real data · NAIC State Based Systems60 verified agents. Average 5.9 years licensed.
Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 2 ZIPs.
Columbus at a glance
Active licenses
100%
60 of 60
License lines
4
distinct authorities
Multi-state
7
licensed in 2+ states
Median tenure
4 yrs
years licensed
Tenure distribution
0-5 yrs51%(24)5-10 yrs15%(7)10-20 yrs21%(10)20+ yrs13%(6)
60 producers licensed here are based outside Indiana (top: FL 48, SC 3, WV 3).
Top lines of authority
Browse by ZIP
Showing 1–30 of 60
Matthew Carothers
Casualty Insurance
404 WASHINGTON ST STE 204
Columbus, IN · 4720126 yrs licensedNPN 817061Lic #D010741
Todd Colvin
Casualty Insurance
305 WASHINGTON ST
Columbus, IN · 4720121 yrs licensedNPN 597571Lic #A052175
Brenda Kindy
Casualty Insurance
CREATIVE BENEFITS ADMINISTRATORS
Columbus, IN · 4720321 yrs licensedNPN 357860Lic #E144985
Robert Banister
Casualty Insurance
BAIRD
Columbus, IN · 4720120 yrs licensedNPN 1478412Lic #P034194
Thomas Mueller
Casualty Insurance
636 3RD ST
Columbus, IN · 4720120 yrs licensedNPN 816850Lic #P033492
Robert Fischvogt
Casualty Insurance
501 WASHINGTON
Columbus, IN · 4720120 yrs licensedNPN 8144017Lic #P001815
Richard Mann
Casualty Insurance
3200 SYCAMORE CT STE 1A
Columbus, IN · 4720318 yrs licensedNPN 7540099Lic #P119411
Ralph Alexander
Casualty Insurance
3963 JONATHAN RIDGE
Columbus, IN · 4720117 yrs licensedNPN 8164357Lic #P196188
Michael Burchfield
Casualty Insurance
EDWARD JONES
Columbus, IN · 4720115 yrs licensedNPN 12804159Lic #W012551
Eric Robbins
Casualty Insurance
EDWARD JONES
Columbus, IN · 4720114 yrs licensedNPN 16001617Lic #W053658
Jodi Engelstad
Casualty Insurance
810 BROWN ST STE C
Columbus, IN · 4720114 yrs licensedNPN 3531258Lic #W089178
James Ostermueller
Casualty Insurance
5532 25TH ST
Columbus, IN · 4720314 yrs licensedNPN 2890332Lic #W101236
Robert Lewis
Casualty Insurance
430 4TH ST
Columbus, IN · 4720112 yrs licensedNPN 3903786Lic #W196270
David Weiss
Casualty Insurance
EDWARD JONES
Columbus, IN · 4720111 yrs licensedNPN 16188004Lic #W258378
Adam Scheidt
Casualty Insurance
404 WASHINGTON ST STE 204
Columbus, IN · 4720110 yrs licensedNPN 13069575Lic #W280667
Stephen Boggs
Casualty Insurance
JJ B HILLIARD WL LYONS LLC
Columbus, IN · 4720110 yrs licensedNPN 1479116Lic #W297027
Daylan Mueller
Casualty Insurance
636 3RD ST
Columbus, IN · 472018 yrs licensedNPN 17480064Lic #W452811
Troy Forman
Casualty Insurance
2635 FOXPOINTE DRIVE
Columbus, IN · 472038 yrs licensedNPN 1507861Lic #W473788
Thorn Murphy
Casualty Insurance
134 WESTWOOD BLVD
Columbus, IN · 472016 yrs licensedNPN 18617374Lic #W587431
Christopher Burnett
Casualty Insurance
3038 STATE ST.
Columbus, IN · 472016 yrs licensedNPN 18109523Lic #W640084
Andrew Robbins
Casualty Insurance
1006 25TH ST
Columbus, IN · 472016 yrs licensedNPN 13336976Lic #W630149
Heath Johnson
Casualty Insurance
1712 CENTRAL AVENUE
Columbus, IN · 472016 yrs licensedNPN 19054760Lic #W623970
John Hayden
Casualty Insurance
723 WASHINGTON ST
Columbus, IN · 472015 yrs licensedNPN 17744255Lic #W674621
Joshua Bontrager
Casualty Insurance
3012 TULIP DR
Columbus, IN · 472034 yrs licensedNPN 20132166Lic #W800670
Andrea Gomez Delgado
Casualty Insurance
3712 ARAPAHOE TRL
Columbus, IN · 472034 yrs licensedNPN 20230712Lic #W862459
Klayton Brummett
Casualty Insurance
3921 PREMIER DRIVE
Columbus, IN · 472034 yrs licensedNPN 20375085Lic #W870185
Darrel J Kemmerer
Life Insurance+Variable
Columbus, IN · 472013 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20262 statesNPN 748368Lic #748368
Andrew Haase
Casualty Insurance
718 3RD ST
Columbus, IN · 472013 yrs licensedNPN 20078768Lic #W893779
Benjamin Stahl
Casualty Insurance
2225 CENTRAL AVE
Columbus, IN · 472013 yrs licensedNPN 15984057Lic #W923895
David Luken
Casualty Insurance
2545 FOX POINTE DR STE E
Columbus, IN · 472033 yrs licensedNPN 20159735Lic #W956209