Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Shelbyville, IN

Real data · NAIC State Based Systems

21 verified agents. Average 1.8 years licensed.

Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 2 ZIPs.

Shelbyville at a glance

Active licenses

100%

21 of 21

License lines

3

distinct authorities

Multi-state

6

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

2 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs92%(12)5-10 yrs0%(0)10-20 yrs8%(1)20+ yrs0%(0)
21 producers licensed here are based outside Indiana (top: FL 11, TN 3, NC 2).

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance11Life Insurance9Property Insurance1

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–21 of 21

David Phares

Casualty Insurance

406 MILLER AVE

Shelbyville, IN · 4617611 yrs licensedNPN 1488051Lic #W260432
active

Heather Hyatt

Casualty Insurance

713 EBERHART DR

Shelbyville, IN · 461764 yrs licensedNPN 20022575Lic #W781717
active

Crystal Neil

Casualty Insurance

22 HOWARD ST

Shelbyville, IN · 461764 yrs licensedNPN 10099988Lic #W795199
active

Justin Berling

Casualty Insurance

1049 SPRINGWAY DRIVE

Shelbyville, IN · 461763 yrs licensedNPN 8847570Lic #P089803
active

Jonathan Ward

Casualty Insurance

2120 WILLOW OAK CT

Shelbyville, IN · 461763 yrs licensedNPN 18539598Lic #W430353
active

Christopher Nolley

Casualty Insurance

NOLLEY INSURANCE GROUP LLC

Shelbyville, IN · 461763 yrs licensedNPN 1480773Lic #W913946
active

Beau Browning

Casualty Insurance

2177 INTELLIPLEX DR STE 201

Shelbyville, IN · 461762 yrs licensedNPN 8493829Lic #W271912
active

Gary Nolley

Casualty Insurance

103 W BOGGSTOWN RD

Shelbyville, IN · 461762 yrs licensedNPN 257108Lic #G060070
active

Bryson Smith

Casualty Insurance

1670 SHELTON DR

Shelbyville, IN · 461762 yrs licensedNPN 21078779Lic #G094078
active

Spencer Allen Zuercher

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Shelbyville, IN · 461761 yrs licensedRenews Aug 20262 statesNPN 18015608Lic #778441
active

Anthony Nigh

Life Insurance+Variable
Shelbyville, IN · 461761 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20262 statesNPN 3314498Lic #2346206
active

Danielle Nicole Ebbert

Life Insurance+Casualty+Property
Shelbyville, IN · 461761 yrs licensedRenews Jun 2027NPN 17903377Lic #3003350062
active

Trevor Johnson

Casualty Insurance

1828 E STATE ROAD 44 STE 100

Shelbyville, IN · 461761 yrs licensedNPN 15837380Lic #G199466
active

Tonya M Ruf

Life Insurance+Variable
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews Sep 20292 statesNPN 16134324Lic #16134324
active

Lezille Monta Arcand

Life Insurance
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews Sep 2027NPN 20608348Lic #3003619878
active

Christopher Renfrow Esser

Life Insurance+Health
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews Mar 20282 statesNPN 16330888Lic #16330888
active

Michael Wayne Neice

Life Insurance+Health
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews Mar 2028NPN 7507646Lic #7507646
active

Jason Busald Pike

Life Insurance+Variable
Shelbyville, IN · 46716Renews Sep 2028NPN 8187276Lic #3001683588
active

Allyne E Shriver

Life Insurance
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews Jun 20272 statesNPN 22218229Lic #22218229
active

Blaine Mikel Condarco

Property Insurance
Shelbyville, IN · 46176Renews May 20292 statesNPN 21337027Lic #3003778612
active

Sallalee Salgado

Casualty Insurance

1693 CARDINAL LANE

Shelbyville, IN · 46176NPN 21670976Lic #G320318
active