Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
Home Missouri Columbia Insurance Agents in Columbia, MO Real data · NAIC State Based Systems365 verified agents. Average 3 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.
Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 9 ZIPs.
Columbia at a glance Tenure distribution
0-5 yrs 73% (171) 5-10 yrs 10% (24) 10-20 yrs 13% (30) 20+ yrs 3% (8)
241 producers licensed here are based outside Missouri (top: FL 169 , KS 15 , AL 10 ).
Browse by ZIP
All ZIPs 65203 152 65201 144 65202 42 65218 15 65217 5 65205 4 65302 1 65109 1 65804 1
All lines Casualty Insurance (98) Life Insurance (2) Showing 1–30 of 100
Ronald Rennolds Casualty Insurance
3002 BIRCHWOOD DR
Columbia, MO · 65202 30 yrs licensed NPN 572664 Lic #A218150 active
John Rentschler Casualty Insurance
3610 BUTTONWOOD DR STE 300
Columbia, MO · 65201 29 yrs licensed NPN 687592 Lic #A218180 active
Stephanie Rothermich Casualty Insurance
110 N 10TH ST STE 5
Columbia, MO · 65201 28 yrs licensed NPN 847406 Lic #A226912 active
Gregory Holloway Casualty Insurance
1000 W NIFONG BLDG 4 SUITE 104
Columbia, MO · 65203 27 yrs licensed NPN 766248 Lic #A317245 active
Betty Schuster Casualty Insurance
SCHUSTER FINANCIAL SERVICES
Columbia, MO · 65203 24 yrs licensed NPN 233715 Lic #D087058 active
Jason Lawless Casualty Insurance
203 E NIFONG BLVD STE AA
Columbia, MO · 65203 21 yrs licensed NPN 7724824 Lic #E145597 active
Peter Graff Casualty Insurance
NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL
Columbia, MO · 65201 21 yrs licensed NPN 889900 Lic #E154038 active
Lonnie Brockmeier Casualty Insurance
709 FAY ST STE 209
Columbia, MO · 65201 21 yrs licensed NPN 854774 Lic #E143397 active
Jared Reynolds Casualty Insurance
1000 W NIFONG BLVD STE 3-220
Columbia, MO · 65203 19 yrs licensed NPN 6047384 Lic #E148452 active
Racheal Sutton Casualty Insurance
1817 W BROADWAY
Columbia, MO · 65218 18 yrs licensed NPN 8711911 Lic #P113272 active
Paula Cunningham Casualty Insurance
1817 W BROADWAY
Columbia, MO · 65218 18 yrs licensed NPN 8571755 Lic #P116038 active
Daniel Pratt Casualty Insurance
1820 W ASH ST
Columbia, MO · 65203 17 yrs licensed NPN 8426780 Lic #P164118 active
William Fretwell Casualty Insurance
3310 BLUFF CREEK DR STE 102
Columbia, MO · 65201 16 yrs licensed NPN 7459482 Lic #P098042 active
Justin Hein Casualty Insurance
1817 W BROADWAY
Columbia, MO · 65218 16 yrs licensed NPN 9689296 Lic #P229732 active
Katherine Tanner Casualty Insurance
5716 EULISS DR
Columbia, MO · 65201 15 yrs licensed NPN 918617 Lic #W004327 active
Joseph Henson Casualty Insurance
4104 HURON CT.
Columbia, MO · 65203 15 yrs licensed NPN 10657730 Lic #W037283 active
Jody Frank Casualty Insurance
4205 PHILIPS FARM RD STE 100
Columbia, MO · 65201 15 yrs licensed NPN 7837415 Lic #W029311 active
Neil Carr Casualty Insurance
401 LOCUST ST STE 204
Columbia, MO · 65201 15 yrs licensed NPN 814096 Lic #W034893 active
Larry Stratton Casualty Insurance
2501 BLUFF CREEK DRIVE
Columbia, MO · 65201 14 yrs licensed NPN 7913101 Lic #W069030 active
Bryan Bolten Casualty Insurance
2310 FORUM BLVD APT C
Columbia, MO · 65203 13 yrs licensed NPN 4996566 Lic #W113151 active
Carroll Wilkerson Casualty Insurance
200 E SOUTHAMPTON DR STE 101
Columbia, MO · 65203 13 yrs licensed NPN 4887834 Lic #W034221 active
George York Casualty Insurance
1600 E POINTE DR
Columbia, MO · 65201 13 yrs licensed NPN 8974869 Lic #W113519 active
George Zimny Casualty Insurance
4507 STONINGTON CT
Columbia, MO · 65203 13 yrs licensed NPN 14919245 Lic #W126432 active
Michael Flanagan Casualty Insurance
1101 CLUB VILLAGE DR
Columbia, MO · 65203 13 yrs licensed NPN 4884182 Lic #W125914 active
Richard Blankenship Casualty Insurance
1101 CLUB VILLAGE DR
Columbia, MO · 65203 12 yrs licensed NPN 715203 Lic #A295685 active
Lannie Emfinger Casualty Insurance
2101 WEST BROADWAY
Columbia, MO · 65203 12 yrs licensed NPN 8278979 Lic #E143890 active
Brent Williams Casualty Insurance
1520 E OAKLAND CHURCH RD
Columbia, MO · 65202 12 yrs licensed NPN 8351589 Lic #E158943 active
Matthew Volk Casualty Insurance
1101 CLUB VILLAGE DR
Columbia, MO · 65203 12 yrs licensed NPN 7843708 Lic #W172133 active
Gregory Reed Casualty Insurance
RAYMOND JAMES FINANCIAL SERVICES
Columbia, MO · 65203 12 yrs licensed NPN 5009108 Lic #W157120 active
Roger Stone Casualty Insurance
1225 JAKE LANE
Columbia, MO · 65203 12 yrs licensed NPN 7991428 Lic #W189907 active Prev1 2 3 4 Next