Insurance Agents in Elmira, NY
Real data · NAIC State Based Systems33 verified agents. Average 9.3 years licensed.
Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 6 ZIPs.
Elmira at a glance
Active licenses
100%
33 of 33
License lines
3
distinct authorities
Multi-state
3
licensed in 2+ states
Median tenure
10 yrs
years licensed
Tenure distribution
0-5 yrs24%(7)5-10 yrs24%(7)10-20 yrs38%(11)20+ yrs14%(4)
33 producers licensed here are based outside New York (top: FL 29, NC 1, MA 1).
Top lines of authority
Browse by ZIP
Showing 1–30 of 33
Richard Goldman
Casualty Insurance
MORGAN STANLEY
Elmira, NY · 1490129 yrs licensedNPN 1015564Lic #A099335
Russell Bancroft
Casualty Insurance
MORGAN STANLEY
Elmira, NY · 1490125 yrs licensedNPN 4794155Lic #D072520
William Reilly
Casualty Insurance
WELLS FARGO ADVISORS
Elmira, NY · 1490123 yrs licensedNPN 2893494Lic #D010435
Rachelle Snyder
Casualty Insurance
METLIFE 94L EMIRA
Elmira, NY · 1490120 yrs licensedNPN 8468319Lic #P029589
Suzanne Valicenti
Casualty Insurance
C/O VALICENTI INSURANCE SERVICES INC
Elmira, NY · 1490119 yrs licensedNPN 6622359Lic #P031995
Andrew Smith
Casualty Insurance
100 W WATER ST
Elmira, NY · 1490118 yrs licensedNPN 9692906Lic #P121764
Jay Sullivan
Casualty Insurance
100 N MAIN ST STE 201
Elmira, NY · 1490115 yrs licensedNPN 8523568Lic #W013581
Deborah Lynch
Casualty Insurance
100 N MAIN ST
Elmira, NY · 1490115 yrs licensedNPN 2011852Lic #W049707
Damien Mustico
Casualty Insurance
221 W CHURCH ST
Elmira, NY · 1490112 yrs licensedNPN 8043173Lic #W161732
Elizabeth Mustico
Casualty Insurance
221 W CHURCH ST
Elmira, NY · 1490112 yrs licensedNPN 16496564Lic #W178917
Kathryn Schermerhorn
Casualty Insurance
447 E WATER STREET
Elmira, NY · 1483012 yrs licensedNPN 7937807Lic #W198915
Justin Faulkner
Casualty Insurance
100 W. CHURCH STREET
Elmira, NY · 1490111 yrs licensedNPN 8628440Lic #W246173
Michael Riley
Casualty Insurance
LPL FINANCIAL
Elmira, NY · 1490111 yrs licensedNPN 769116Lic #W221051
Kelly Shaw
Casualty Insurance
303 W WATER ST
Elmira, NY · 1490111 yrs licensedNPN 16934547Lic #W255822
Peter Mcevoy
Casualty Insurance
100 WEST CHURCH STREET
Elmira, NY · 1490110 yrs licensedNPN 17098068Lic #W293398
John Brand
Casualty Insurance
930 W CHURCH ST
Elmira, NY · 149059 yrs licensedNPN 18079291Lic #W367945
Heather Wilbur
Casualty Insurance
100 N MAIN ST STE 201
Elmira, NY · 149017 yrs licensedNPN 17957293Lic #W529805
Steven Shumway
Casualty Insurance
97 CHERRYWOOD MANOR DR
Elmira, NY · 149047 yrs licensedNPN 18780529Lic #W549218
Sabrina Chilson
Casualty Insurance
1 CHEMUNG CANAL PLAZA
Elmira, NY · 149017 yrs licensedNPN 18307476Lic #W578219
Richard White
Casualty Insurance
WELLS FARGO ADVISOR
Elmira, NY · 149017 yrs licensedNPN 2507231Lic #W549308
Michael Morse
Casualty Insurance
150 BALDWIN ST SUITE A
Elmira, NY · 149015 yrs licensedNPN 7367345Lic #P027399
Christopher Petrillose
Casualty Insurance
PERRY & CARROLL, INC
Elmira, NY · 149015 yrs licensedNPN 16627680Lic #W739405
Jonathan Kravitz
Casualty Insurance
1260 W. CHURCH ST.
Elmira, NY · 149054 yrs licensedNPN 695698Lic #W793241
Thomas Chadwell
Casualty Insurance
726 HARRIS HILL RD
Elmira, NY · 149034 yrs licensedNPN 20361579Lic #W866306
Steven Strong
Casualty Insurance
143 WHITETAIL DRIVE
Elmira, NY · 149033 yrs licensedNPN 2011754Lic #E075158
Kara Sweet Argetsinger
Property Insurance+Casualty
Elmira, NY · 149052 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20262 statesNPN 16698903Lic #16698903
Joseph Gill
Casualty Insurance
120 HENDY CREEK RD # A
Elmira, NY · 149052 yrs licensedNPN 20642203Lic #W958623
Jill Marie Boyce
Life Insurance+Variable
Elmira, NY · 149011 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20272 statesNPN 20210718Lic #20210718
Beverly Burns
Casualty Insurance
521 W GRAY ST
Elmira, NY · 149051 yrs licensedNPN 21060213Lic #G157034
Jacqueline Elizabeth Cisco
Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Elmira, NY · 14901Renews Mar 20282 statesNPN 19223187Lic #19223187