Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Lancaster, NY

Real data · NAIC State Based Systems

23 verified agents. Average 6.2 years licensed.

Data verified July 13, 2026 from NAIC State Based Systems (public license lookup). Covers 1 ZIP.

Lancaster at a glance

Active licenses

100%

23 of 23

License lines

4

distinct authorities

Multi-state

4

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

5 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs44%(8)5-10 yrs28%(5)10-20 yrs22%(4)20+ yrs6%(1)
23 producers licensed here are based outside New York (top: FL 15, NC 3, NJ 1).

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance15Life Insurance5Property Insurance2Health Insurance1

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–23 of 23

Alan Justin

Casualty Insurance

19 SUGARBUSH LANE

Lancaster, NY · 1408637 yrs licensedNPN 438471Lic #A135887
active

Thomas Carlsen

Casualty Insurance

5 WEST MAIN STREET

Lancaster, NY · 1408616 yrs licensedNPN 955684Lic #P225234
active

Kathleen Garby

Casualty Insurance

56 WILLIAMSBURG LN

Lancaster, NY · 1408615 yrs licensedNPN 7539606Lic #W021518
active

Jay Gianni

Casualty Insurance

18 HILLSIDE PKWY

Lancaster, NY · 1408613 yrs licensedNPN 2088948Lic #W137231
active

Charles Snyder

Casualty Insurance

3725 WALDEN AVE

Lancaster, NY · 1408611 yrs licensedNPN 9165179Lic #W239009
active

Robert Zaidel

Casualty Insurance

26 NORRIS AVE

Lancaster, NY · 140868 yrs licensedNPN 4651315Lic #W414579
active

Sally Stier

Casualty Insurance

102 SIXTH AVE

Lancaster, NY · 140867 yrs licensedNPN 8929571Lic #W510177
active

Lisa Giancarlo

Casualty Insurance

25 SAGEBRUSH LANE

Lancaster, NY · 140867 yrs licensedNPN 9743688Lic #W512289
active

Michael Schaefer

Casualty Insurance

51 PARK BLVD

Lancaster, NY · 140866 yrs licensedNPN 8775026Lic #W532406
active

Clint Schaefer

Casualty Insurance

51 PARK BLVD

Lancaster, NY · 140865 yrs licensedNPN 18935923Lic #W721261
active

Daniel Della Sala

Casualty Insurance

91 COUNTRY PLACE

Lancaster, NY · 140864 yrs licensedNPN 418453Lic #A065381
active

Anne Marie Sacco

Life Insurance
Lancaster, NY · 140863 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2026NPN 15356136Lic #15356136
active

Jamie Miller

Casualty Insurance

1964 COMO PARK BLVD

Lancaster, NY · 140863 yrs licensedNPN 20342950Lic #W865914
active

Brian Kroll

Casualty Insurance

5329 BROADWAY ST

Lancaster, NY · 140863 yrs licensedNPN 14386909Lic #W965699
active

Danny Koch-Thomas

Health Insurance
Lancaster, NY · 140861 yrs licensedRenews Oct 20262 statesNPN 16897459Lic #16897459
active

Giselle M Jackman

Life Insurance+Health
Lancaster, NY · 140861 yrs licensedRenews Aug 2027NPN 17380134Lic #17380134
active

Garett Farrugia

Casualty Insurance

ROBERT E. SCHAFF LTD

Lancaster, NY · 140861 yrs licensedNPN 16359126Lic #G214324
active

Nicholas Neisen

Casualty Insurance

60 GARFIELD ST

Lancaster, NY · 140861 yrs licensedNPN 16422953Lic #G250838
active

Robert Kupiec

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Lancaster, NY · 14086Renews Dec 20272 statesNPN 21644483Lic #3004008850
active

Jillian Joyce Cipolla

Life Insurance
Lancaster, NY · 14086Renews Mar 2028NPN 20794849Lic #20794849
active

Arthur C Mcrae

Life Insurance+Health
Lancaster, NY · 14086Renews Mar 2028NPN 2311127Lic #2311127
active

Michael A Szymanski

Property Insurance
Lancaster, NY · 14086Renews Mar 20282 statesNPN 17390070Lic #17390070
active

David E Over

Property Insurance+Casualty
Lancaster, NY · 14086Renews Aug 20272 statesNPN 9101490Lic #3002385468
active