Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Garrettsville, OH

Real data · Ohio Department of Insurance

148 verified agents. Average 5.4 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.

Data verified July 9, 2026 from Ohio Department of Insurance (public license data). Covers 4 ZIPs.

Garrettsville at a glance

Active licenses

100%

148 of 148

License lines

5

distinct authorities

Multi-state

11

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

5 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs0%(0)5-10 yrs100%(148)10-20 yrs0%(0)20+ yrs0%(0)

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance125Life Insurance15Property Insurance5Health Insurance2Title Insurance1

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–30 of 100

Tonya Mcmahan

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20282 statesNPN 20241633Lic #1421807
active

Tracy Wem

Property Insurance+Casualty
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20286 statesNPN 2209593Lic #31760
active

Shawn Barber

Life Insurance+Health
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2027NPN 21264911Lic #1602468
active

Lauren Bernotas

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Apr 20282 statesNPN 20980114Lic #1546246
active

Tina Casto

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Aug 2027NPN 7409013Lic #611198
active

Helene Christopher

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2028NPN 21100311Lic #690253
active

Mickey Christopher

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 97011Lic #77641
active

Amy Dickey

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20272 statesNPN 20803557Lic #1524593
active

Rachael Geissinger

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 17556821Lic #1062022
active

Holly Harper

Property Insurance+Casualty
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20272 statesNPN 10427015Lic #758861
active

Lisa Haylett

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews May 2028NPN 17849277Lic #1096179
active

Amber Hermann

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jun 2028NPN 16775937Lic #970133
active

James Irwin

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Aug 2027NPN 10370950Lic #757718
active

Caitlin Lawless

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 16589575Lic #956687
active

Lauren Lowry

Life Insurance+Health
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2028NPN 21173244Lic #1583134
active

Roger Moorman

Health Insurance
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Nov 2027NPN 7100151Lic #1690926
active

Jeffrey Rickerman

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20282 statesNPN 21740912Lic #1702981
active

Henry Paul

Property Insurance+Health+Life+Variable
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2027NPN 8214790Lic #661103
active

Matthew Ryser

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2028NPN 2772070Lic #22005
active

Emma Traggiai

Life Insurance+Health
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2028NPN 21770153Lic #1701515
active

Rachel Rice

Title Insurance
Garrettsville, OH · 442318 yrs licensedRenews Nov 2027NPN 17801349Lic #1090390
active

Jessica Mcknight

Property Insurance+Casualty
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20172 statesNPN 17749877Lic #1083580
active

Joann Blank

Casualty Insurance+Health+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2006NPN 5715635Lic #590428
active

Samuel Cain

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2010NPN 14068181Lic #791926
active

Sean Carlson

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews May 2014NPN 3239485Lic #546233
active

Ted Christopher

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2017NPN 17201645Lic #1086014
active

Gretchen Cram

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2013NPN 3242724Lic #546165
active

Dorothy Culp

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2009NPN 7902609Lic #638625
active

Michael Ellinos

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2008NPN 1767177Lic #624825
active

Robert Gartman

Casualty Insurance+Property
Garrettsville, OH · 442315 yrs licensedRenews Nov 2012NPN 7042046Lic #595900
active