Insurance Agents in New Carlisle, OH
Real data · Ohio Department of Insurance380 verified agents. Average 5.3 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.
Data verified July 13, 2026 from Ohio Department of Insurance (public license data). Covers 5 ZIPs.
New Carlisle at a glance
Active licenses
100%
380 of 380
License lines
5
distinct authorities
Multi-state
7
licensed in 2+ states
Median tenure
5 yrs
years licensed
Tenure distribution
0-5 yrs0%(1)5-10 yrs100%(379)10-20 yrs0%(0)20+ yrs0%(0)
1 producers licensed here are based outside Ohio (top: FL 1).
Browse by ZIP
Showing 1–30 of 100
Tyler Mougey
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Mar 20272 statesNPN 21714655Lic #1692730
Megan Estep
Casualty Insurance+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 21720353Lic #1688952
Tim Adams
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 19885304Lic #1364508
Oscar Alvarez
Life Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 21734122Lic #1690712
Katelynn Atkins
Life Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 22141765Lic #1725981
Kimberly Auten
Property Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20272 statesNPN 19774182Lic #1709819
Storm Capper
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2027NPN 21464208Lic #1642186
Cacar Carmickal
Casualty Insurance+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 19943584Lic #1568623
Sherri Devlin
Life Insurance+Health+Variable
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2027NPN 18546927Lic #1165225
Elijah Diraimondo
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Nov 2027NPN 22061797Lic #1711019
Annie Dudley
Casualty Insurance+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 19943655Lic #1371084
Isiah Fairley
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2028NPN 20776434Lic #1522899
William Furay
Life Insurance+Variable
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 17135974Lic #1013195
Richard Hardacre
Health Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews May 2027NPN 21664836Lic #1675464
Zachary Harrison
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews May 2027NPN 16378234Lic #939481
Nathaniel Hayes
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 21614402Lic #1667038
William Heard
Life Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jun 2027NPN 21568875Lic #1655300
Randall Helt
Life Insurance+Health+Variable
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20272 statesNPN 2777538Lic #19502
Peter Holm
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Dec 2027NPN 20234296Lic #1421498
Douglas Kilfoyle
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews May 2028NPN 1840656Lic #39350
Elizabeth King
Life Insurance+Health
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2028NPN 4705279Lic #1270059
Christopher Larkins
Life Insurance
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Sep 2027NPN 21777446Lic #1705353
Kathy Lewis
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 1857578Lic #80288
M Mougey
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2028NPN 1785134Lic #70827
Rhonda Vanhoose
Life Insurance+Health+Variable
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2028NPN 7484760Lic #615037
Angela Paradiso
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jun 2028NPN 21356761Lic #1620397
Rick Pollock
Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2027NPN 12221663Lic #777677
Holly Pyles
Casualty Insurance+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2027NPN 21622327Lic #1665680
Kimberly Richards
Casualty Insurance+Property
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2027NPN 10666552Lic #761719
Shawna Schaefer
Life Insurance+Health+Variable
New Carlisle, OH · 453448 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 11578835Lic #772407