Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Toledo, OH

Real data · Ohio Department of Insurance

9,073 verified agents. Average 5.3 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.

Data verified July 13, 2026 from Ohio Department of Insurance (public license data). Covers 75 ZIPs.

Toledo at a glance

Active licenses

100%

9,073 of 9,073

License lines

5

distinct authorities

Multi-state

311

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

5 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs0%(18)5-10 yrs100%(9,046)10-20 yrs0%(3)20+ yrs0%(4)
32 producers licensed here are based outside Ohio (top: FL 28, SC 2, DE 2).

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance8,146Life Insurance799Property Insurance67Health Insurance38Title Insurance23

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–30 of 100

Angela Wingerd

Casualty Insurance

7150 W CENTRAL AVE STE 100

Toledo, OH · 4361729 yrs licensedNPN 994701Lic #A288109
active

Betsy Ruiz

Property Insurance+Casualty

MELTING POT INSURANCE LLC

Toledo, OH · 4361326 yrs licensedNPN 1920524Lic #D035361
active

Keith Mitchell

Casualty Insurance

3230 CENTRAL PARK W STE 201

Toledo, OH · 4361724 yrs licensedNPN 298185Lic #E031194
active

Krista Girrbach

Casualty Insurance

7311 CROSSLEIGH CT

Toledo, OH · 4361720 yrs licensedNPN 984915Lic #P048928
active

Rance Miller

Casualty Insurance

3400 EXECUTIVE PKWY

Toledo, OH · 4360611 yrs licensedNPN 17081577Lic #W206832
active

Kimberly Brown

Casualty Insurance

HYLANT ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES, LLC

Toledo, OH · 4360411 yrs licensedNPN 16156813Lic #W215695
active

Lyntoya Carson

Casualty Insurance

711 MORAN AVE

Toledo, OH · 4360710 yrs licensedNPN 17885110Lic #W312648
active

Lindcii Craig

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Toledo, OH · 436068 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20272 statesNPN 20665734Lic #1675460
active

Ryan Conlan

Property Insurance+Casualty
Toledo, OH · 436158 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20272 statesNPN 21001986Lic #1550546
active

Elaine Cahill

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436178 yrs licensedRenews Apr 20272 statesNPN 7407617Lic #610829
active

Sarah Fletcher

Life Insurance+Health
Toledo, OH · 436048 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20272 statesNPN 20074806Lic #1503100
active

Christine Wiskochil

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436138 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20272 statesNPN 16497024Lic #950571
active

Fidelia Senayah

Life Insurance
Toledo, OH · 436238 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20272 statesNPN 20730303Lic #1510331
active

Kalin Emans

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436068 yrs licensedRenews May 20272 statesNPN 19195410Lic #1243674
active

Vanessa Sgro

Property Insurance+Casualty
Toledo, OH · 436138 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20272 statesNPN 20261561Lic #1425148
active

Renee Swaby

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436158 yrs licensedRenews Sep 20282 statesNPN 2557552Lic #64111
active

Stephen Baehren

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436158 yrs licensedRenews Apr 20282 statesNPN 1682257Lic #9237
active

Martin Bokesch

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436068 yrs licensedRenews Mar 20282 statesNPN 968127Lic #24747
active

Brianna Budd

Life Insurance+Health
Toledo, OH · 436048 yrs licensedRenews May 20273 statesNPN 19297581Lic #1262022
active

Eric Croak

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436048 yrs licensedRenews May 20273 statesNPN 17682380Lic #1073150
active

Timothy Croak

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436068 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20282 statesNPN 2831490Lic #6528
active

Matthew Darah

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436238 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20285 statesNPN 17309542Lic #1030559
active

David Elrod

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436158 yrs licensedRenews Mar 20272 statesNPN 8267688Lic #663003
active

Joshua Erd

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Toledo, OH · 436068 yrs licensedRenews Apr 20282 statesNPN 19611619Lic #1310265
active

Christopher Heerdegen

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436178 yrs licensedRenews Aug 20272 statesNPN 985796Lic #929
active

Thomas Hudak

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436138 yrs licensedRenews Jul 20282 statesNPN 9725112Lic #744786
active

Michael Nusbaum

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436178 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20282 statesNPN 1003279Lic #10406
active

John Payak

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Toledo, OH · 436048 yrs licensedRenews Aug 20282 statesNPN 511497Lic #1641503
active

Daniel Peffley

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436178 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20272 statesNPN 7133108Lic #600197
active

Dominic Pisanti

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Toledo, OH · 436048 yrs licensedRenews May 20282 statesNPN 17823820Lic #1094056
active