Data enrichment in progress: Some agents may be missing or state licensing info may not fully reflect all states where an agent is practicing. We're adding more states weekly.
iAgentProof

Insurance Agents in Utica, OH

Real data · Ohio Department of Insurance

126 verified agents. Average 5.5 years licensed. Showing the top 100 by tenure — for a specific agent, verify with the state DOI.

Data verified July 13, 2026 from Ohio Department of Insurance (public license data). Covers 4 ZIPs.

Utica at a glance

Active licenses

100%

126 of 126

License lines

4

distinct authorities

Multi-state

11

licensed in 2+ states

Median tenure

5 yrs

years licensed

Tenure distribution

0-5 yrs1%(1)5-10 yrs99%(125)10-20 yrs0%(0)20+ yrs0%(0)
2 producers licensed here are based outside Ohio (top: FL 2).

Top lines of authority

Casualty Insurance104Life Insurance18Property Insurance3Title Insurance1

Browse by ZIP

Showing 1–30 of 100

Jesse Crabtree

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20272 statesNPN 19970037Lic #1372107
active

Aaron Ward

Life Insurance
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Feb 20272 statesNPN 18143392Lic #1125034
active

Adrienne Ward

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Aug 20272 statesNPN 22125076Lic #1723103
active

Francine Brewer

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2027NPN 21727864Lic #1688670
active

Stephanie Green

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jan 20282 statesNPN 8476669Lic #678499
active

Taylor Johnson

Life Insurance
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Oct 2027NPN 21679277Lic #1679196
active

Susan Leavens

Life Insurance
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2028NPN 21398286Lic #1626359
active

Julie Loy

Property Insurance+Health+Life+Variable
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2028NPN 15503139Lic #806131
active

Mark Mckimmins

Casualty Insurance+Health+Life+Property+1 more
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Aug 2027NPN 1900531Lic #6253
active

Joseph Montis

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 22174762Lic #1733066
active

Jacob Nelson

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 19594251Lic #1301963
active

Rachel O Quinn

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2027NPN 19987909Lic #1372312
active

Sally Ray

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2027NPN 19268399Lic #1255442
active

Carrie Rine

Property Insurance+Casualty
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20273 statesNPN 18701961Lic #1181897
active

Shannon Staugh

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2028NPN 19333766Lic #1268931
active

Broc Stradley

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Aug 2027NPN 18375306Lic #1144416
active

Robert Thompson

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jun 2027NPN 8031575Lic #650243
active

Stephanie Vinion

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Aug 20282 statesNPN 20453229Lic #1460993
active

David Williams

Life Insurance+Health
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Feb 2028NPN 21273497Lic #1599701
active

Hannah Yoder

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2027NPN 19943766Lic #1366291
active

Lacy Runyon

Casualty Insurance

6532 COSS RD

Utica, OH · 430808 yrs licensedNPN 6383154Lic #W198550
active

Shannon Stevens

Life Insurance+Casualty+Health+Property+1 more
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Nov 20262 statesNPN 1901727Lic #39456
active

Jesse Marcum

Life Insurance+Health+Variable
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Jun 20262 statesNPN 19393989Lic #1300632
active

Stacey Allen

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Dec 2014NPN 12377857Lic #779130
active

Herman Buckenberger

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Jul 2012NPN 7827602Lic #634296
active

John Cascioli

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Apr 2021NPN 17172451Lic #1157861
active

Tyler Crall

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Dec 2020NPN 1888762Lic #816123
active

Kelli Dotson

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews May 2015NPN 1752692Lic #993977
active

Anna Evans

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Jan 2013NPN 7814232Lic #632846
active

Marcy Holton

Casualty Insurance+Property
Utica, OH · 430805 yrs licensedRenews Mar 2022NPN 17951865Lic #1107429
active